The Audi CEO recently said that Global Cars are dead. A Statement I find worth further analyzing. The quote goes like this:
“It’s crystal clear that the global car for the era of the global product is over”
It’s easy to understand what he’s saying by this. Gernot Döllner thinks that a market place where cars are globally competitive is fading away. But the statement needs more nuance, we need to understand where this statement is coming from. Audi and the whole German car industry are significantly dropping in profitability, all due to the rise of Chinese EVs. So it’s not like Audis no longer have global demand. There are still lots of people who would love to drive an Audi, but when the Chinese competitors are way cheaper with way better performance and way more features. Most people who aren’t car enthusiasts just choose the more economical option.
So “the global car” isn’t dead, it’s dead for all non-competitive brands. The “global car” is very alive for China. When they sell 900 HP SUV’s for dirt cheap, you don’t hear them publicly spewing that kind of sentiment. I’m not saying that to bash our German brands, but it’s hard to compete in a global market where most people don’t care about the engine, looks or heritage of a car and it’s brand. And this isn’t something Audi can fix by itself, as far as I see it, this is a political issue. The German state needs to either highly tax China for any cars they sell or outright ban them from being sold here, in order to let the German brands recover.
Obviously that would cause similar retaliatory actions from the Chinese government, which means the VW-Group could lose 30% of their sales which happen in the Chinese market. But just outweigh the consequences of both, VW-Group either loses 30% of their sales but can start dominating the European car market again, or they keep trying to compete with the Chinese brands by making uglier and uglier electric cars just to eventually lose almost all of its market share.
The cheap Labour and cheaper access to materials isn’t even what makes these Chinese companies like Xiaomi more competitive, because we also outsource alot of the production process to third-world countries for cheap labour. What actually makes these brands so much more viable is the fact that car manufacturing is essentially a side hustle for them. Xiaomi makes phones, Dreame Technology makes vacuums, BYD makes batteries, NIO makes in-house accessories and apparel. So even if they were to lose some money from car production, they generate so much more money from selling other things that it doesn’t even matter. Meanwhile VW’s side hustle of selling Sausages is doing them no favors to help their financial situation.
What is even worse is that VW leadership see the solution to their problem in cutting costs.
As if letting hundreds of people go and shutting locations down will suddenly make VW profitable again. As if that will convince more people to buy their cars.
To add insult to injury, not only is VW’s profitability dropping, but the government isn’t even subsidizing them. The German state is watching as some of the countries most important cultural brands slowly fall into financial ruins. Meanwhile China provides substantial subsidies and financial support to its own automotive industry. Since 2009 China spent 230 billion $ to build a global lead in the EV market.
The modern car was born in Germany, so you’d hope the government would support the branch more. More than anything it’s sad to see. I don’t think the government will do anything at all. The VW-Group just needs to figure out how to become more competitive or lobby for Chinese cars to be taxed more.
So the statement of the Audi CEO just seems like a cheap justification for their lack of competitiveness. I hope that the financial struggles of the VW-Group result in some crazy sport cars in a desperate act to boost sales instead of hundreds of lost jobs. Specifically, I hope we see a production W12 Nardo as a cheap Supercar.
Photo source: https://www.moveelectric.com/de-de/e-cars/audi-will-den-beliebten-modellnamen-fur-ein-neues-elektrofahrzeug-wiederbeleben